dnmun
1 PW
"Does this mean I have a bad cell? Could this be the cause? Perhaps the BMS is in fact working - If this cell is bad and tripping the battery BMS LVC during discharge, it would all make sense, no?"
you should verify that the cell is not just balancing to the 3.33V level, and not allowing more than the 3.33V to build up before the shunt turns on. because of a miscalibration of the resistor divider bridge to the comparator on that channel.
no reason not to open it to work on it. i don't think paul really warrants things once you use them and if the BMS channel is miscalibrated, then i suspect he would wanna know that.
so you really have to actually charge that cell up to at least 3.65V while the others are fully charged and run it through several discharge cycles to see where the cell balances again. that's why it helps to measure the individual cell voltages while charging. to see where they balance. you do not know if it is a runt or if it is just not getting fully charged.
you should verify that the cell is not just balancing to the 3.33V level, and not allowing more than the 3.33V to build up before the shunt turns on. because of a miscalibration of the resistor divider bridge to the comparator on that channel.
no reason not to open it to work on it. i don't think paul really warrants things once you use them and if the BMS channel is miscalibrated, then i suspect he would wanna know that.
so you really have to actually charge that cell up to at least 3.65V while the others are fully charged and run it through several discharge cycles to see where the cell balances again. that's why it helps to measure the individual cell voltages while charging. to see where they balance. you do not know if it is a runt or if it is just not getting fully charged.