I just received, from the USA warehouse, a set of six 5Ah/6S/20C Turnigy Lipo packs and, not unexpectedly, it looks like I may have a couple of dud cells.
Pack 1 (s/n *3629855) data:
Pack 1 cell voltages upon unboxing:
cell voltage
1. 3.849
2. 3.850
3. 3.855
4. 3.784 *-possible stinker
5. 3.851
6. 3.854
I charged the pack (using the iCharger 208b) to 4.15V/cell @ 1A. I was able to put in 2.516Ah in 3h45min. Unfortunately I lost the charge curve data as I forgot to plug in my laptop and it died prior to saving the log file. Anyway, it took the alomost 4 hours as it was trying to get cell 4 to catch up with the others. I then did a 0.8A (max of my 208b) discharge to 3.7V/cell. The discharge curve is shown below. I would have to guess that this cell 4 is a dud. It's a tenth of a volt out from the others under a very small load (.16C) and from the graph you can see it starting to go 'over the cliff' at about 3.68V.
View attachment Pack1discharge.pdf
Pack 6 (s/n *3629818) data:
Pack 6 cell voltages upon unboxing:
cell voltage
1. 3.849
2. 3.853
3. 3.851
4. 3.851
5. 3.849
6. 3.805 *-possible stinker
In this pack cell 6 arrived .045V below the others. I charged this pack to 4.15V/cell @ 1A and after 4h37min I put 2.839Ah into the pack. It basically took an hour longer to balance than pack 1. Below is the charge curve.
View attachment Pack6charge.pdf
I then performed a discharge @ 0.8A and there was no indication that cell 6 had a problem. I have yet to charge this pack again to see how long it takes to balance. Here is the discharge curve.
View attachment 3629818discharge1.pdf
For reference the other 4 packs took about 2.5 hours and about 2.15Ah during their initial charge out of the box. I have not done any discharge cycles on them yet. Also there is no evidence of puffing on any of the 6 packs. My thoughts so far:
Pack 1, cell 4 is a dud
Pack 6, cell 6 might be ok
I am going to do a few more cycles and then I'll be contacting Hobby King.
Martin
Pack 1 (s/n *3629855) data:
Pack 1 cell voltages upon unboxing:
cell voltage
1. 3.849
2. 3.850
3. 3.855
4. 3.784 *-possible stinker
5. 3.851
6. 3.854
I charged the pack (using the iCharger 208b) to 4.15V/cell @ 1A. I was able to put in 2.516Ah in 3h45min. Unfortunately I lost the charge curve data as I forgot to plug in my laptop and it died prior to saving the log file. Anyway, it took the alomost 4 hours as it was trying to get cell 4 to catch up with the others. I then did a 0.8A (max of my 208b) discharge to 3.7V/cell. The discharge curve is shown below. I would have to guess that this cell 4 is a dud. It's a tenth of a volt out from the others under a very small load (.16C) and from the graph you can see it starting to go 'over the cliff' at about 3.68V.
View attachment Pack1discharge.pdf
Pack 6 (s/n *3629818) data:
Pack 6 cell voltages upon unboxing:
cell voltage
1. 3.849
2. 3.853
3. 3.851
4. 3.851
5. 3.849
6. 3.805 *-possible stinker
In this pack cell 6 arrived .045V below the others. I charged this pack to 4.15V/cell @ 1A and after 4h37min I put 2.839Ah into the pack. It basically took an hour longer to balance than pack 1. Below is the charge curve.
View attachment Pack6charge.pdf
I then performed a discharge @ 0.8A and there was no indication that cell 6 had a problem. I have yet to charge this pack again to see how long it takes to balance. Here is the discharge curve.
View attachment 3629818discharge1.pdf
For reference the other 4 packs took about 2.5 hours and about 2.15Ah during their initial charge out of the box. I have not done any discharge cycles on them yet. Also there is no evidence of puffing on any of the 6 packs. My thoughts so far:
Pack 1, cell 4 is a dud
Pack 6, cell 6 might be ok
I am going to do a few more cycles and then I'll be contacting Hobby King.
Martin