9S10P outrunner motor , will it work ?

athlon

100 mW
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
44
Hello , somenone have experience in outrunner with 9 slot 10 magnetpole configuration?

It will run smooth or il will be unbalanced? From the windings looks unbalanced but with a rethinking the vector from the 3 phases should balance.
 

Attachments

  • 9s10m.png
    9s10m.png
    38.8 KB · Views: 547
Hi athlon,

It will be unbalanced.

Chapter 5 of the Islam thesis goes into this in some detail:
http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=639311#p639311
 
ok , got it .

It will turn , current will be banced but it will be unbalanced the mechanical force vector , a lot of noise and the bearing will suffer a lot and with this configuration there is nothing you can do ( skewing , magnet shape or other solution)

BTW reading the thesis I never thinked about magnet shape (page 92 of the thesis) for having a more sinusoidal BEMF.

custom shaped magnet can be very expensive but if someone is using a lot of small magnet maybe it can use different magnetization strengt to shape the field.

something like

----N30-N40-N45-N40-N30------N30-N40-N45-N40-N30------N30-N40-N45-N40-N30------N30-N40-N45-N40-N30---

also it can be a little cheaper becuse some magnet can be with lower magnetization.
 
Back
Top