Hi,freexxx said:Hi
Can you please tell me what is the difference between casaini and mbrusa version. Is the mbrusa version an improvement on the casaini version? Which is better and more stable these days?
Thanks
I think the Casainho version has now been replaced by Mbrusa's as he now includes versions for all types of displays. However the firmware for the Bafang displays is still fairly new so there may be further developments.
I first tried Casainho's version 1.1 with the SW102 display and found it difficult to access the Config menu. The main problem was the up and down buttons are designed as a rocker switch and difficult to press both at the same time. Whilst I could sometimes get into the menu this was very frustrating. It put me off changing other settings to make the bike work as I wanted. Having set up the essentials and leaving the rest at default the power distribution was very poor: little power at the start and too much at high cadence. The Wiki instructions still say "start boost buggy", there is also a confusion between "enable and disable" on this function. Also taking the display apart and attaching programming wires was fiddly. After a month or so I gave up and went back to the stock firmware. The Tongsheng kit does work pretty well straight out of the box. However it lacks power at higher pedal cadence.
Then I tried the Mbrusa version 20.1C for the original displays. I have the small VLCD6 and really like it. I was initially worried about downloading and installing various programs to my pc. But it all worked. It's easy to set up with very well written instructions. Using the Java configurator program was straightforward. Having now ridden around 2000km with this firmware I've had no problems and would recommend it to anyone. I ride a full suss mountain bike and set the eMTB mode as default. I've reset the levels to 3,6,9,12 and also have street mode enabled on startup. The strange multiple lights pressing seems odd at first but once you've got it it's easy to remember and very clever.
Of course Casainho deserves huge credit as the original creator of the OS firmware, and also to many others who contributed, however Mbrusa's (for the original displays) is a really user friendly version and to my knowledge totally finished and bug free.