Chalo said:
It's the guns. They're the thing that differs most from everybody else. I bet if you looked at homicides not using guns, our murder rate would line up nicely with the other economic peers.
It's going to be quite hard to prove that point.
The United States has many more guns per person than anyone else.. yet.. there are hundreds of countries that are exponentially more violent that have a fraction of the guns.
View attachment 2
Guns may make it easier to murder, ya... but across the world, plenty of people with murderous intent have no problem killing a lot of people without them.
You've surely noticed that the UK is a more peaceful place than here in the USA..
.. but they have their problem areas where no amount of 'knife control' works out for them.
What's the difference between those areas? it's not access to weapons.
Same goes for America..
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/homicide_mortality/homicide.htm
Like Texas, Utah absolutely loves it's guns.. in fact, our gun ownership rate is a bit higher than Texans'.
..yet Utah's murder rate is 3 times lower.
..and if you look at a map of gun ownership rate in the USA and compare it to homicide rates.. you will find that the link between 'more guns' = 'more murder' to be a quite loose correlation - it's absolutely all over the map.
It turns out that access to certain weapons is one of the least effective ways to determine whether a place is murder-y or not.
A better way to figure out whether a place is murder-y is:
+ Is there a healthy society/culture in the area?
+ What percentage of the people are living in desperation?
+ What's the level of education there?
+ Are there any racial/sexual/cultural/religious conflicts in the area?
These are the questions i ask before i move to a particular area. If i judged Utah on the basis that i saw tons of gun range/seller billboards all over the main metro freeway, i would have been dead wrong on my threat assessment.
The real problem with weapons is the people who chose to use them maliciously. If you desire safety, don't get away from guns, get away from ( or fix ) places with large populations of crazy/degenerate/dissheveled/desperate people. Switching out guns for knives and black market guns won't do much to make an unsafe area safer.
Going after the root causes of violent behavior will be more effective than chasing it's symptoms.